The sign over the old Kmart doors at 2102 Montauk Highway has white letters on a gray field, and it is not lit from inside. The concrete spheres between the entrance and the parking lot, red outside every other Target in the country, are gray here too. Shoppers who pulled into Bridgehampton Commons for the ribbon cutting on Tuesday, October 6, found what Dan's Papers described as a jammed parking lot and a Starbucks line that "went all the way to the back of the massive store."
The gray comes out of a 2025 negotiation with the Southampton Town Planning Board and the Commons' own signage regulations. That negotiation is the latest round in an argument over this building that started before it was built. The new store is the fifth discount chain to fill the same box.
A building that opened over a petition
The structure went up in 1972 as part of the Plaza East Shopping Center. According to The East Hampton Star, a group of residents from Bridgehampton and nearby towns, among them the writer Peter Matthiessen and the artist Saul Steinberg, printed a petition in the paper under the name "Citizens Against the Shopping Center." It warned that the project would cause traffic congestion, compete unfairly with established merchants, and "irreparably alter the visual quality of our countryside."
The plans went ahead anyway. Here is how the space has changed hands since, as reported by the Star, Dan's Papers and 27east:
| Years | Tenant | How it ended |
|---|---|---|
| October 1972 to 1976 | W.T. Grant | Chain went bankrupt |
| 1976 to 1983 | Woolco | Every remaining U.S. Woolco closed |
| 1983 to May 1999 | Caldor | Chain went bankrupt |
| November 1999 to October 2024 | Kmart | Last full-size Kmart in the mainland U.S. |
| October 2026 to present | Target | Opened October 6 |
Kimco, which still owns the center, bought Plaza East and in 1983 asked the town board to expand onto the neighboring site of a former drive-in movie theater. The Star reports that the request drew more protests and legal action, and that the expansion eventually became the Bridgehampton Commons that stands there now.
What the Planning Board asked of Target
Target signed its lease in late 2024 and filed an initial site plan with the Southampton Town Planning Board that December. The main negotiation came at a March 2025 meeting, and the Town issued a building permit covering interior and exterior work on July 30, 2025.
The Star summed up the result as "an uncharacteristically de-Targeted Target." The sign terms were already set before that meeting. It would have white letters and a logo on gray, it could not be internally illuminated under the Commons' own signage rules, and its size had to fit a set ratio to the height of the facade.
The bollards took more discussion. One board member said the red spheres sat "somewhere between an architectural element and a safety issue and signage," and suggested the company get a formal interpretation. Ken McQuade, an in-house Target architect, offered to repaint them. When white came up as an option, he answered, "Respectfully, white shows every scuff and every mark," and proposed a neutral gray to match the sign. Later that March, town building inspector Marjorie Reilly settled it in an email:
"The bollards painted red would be considered a sign ... painted gray would not be considered a sign."
Parking took longer to settle. 27east reported that the store needed to give up six parking spots to fit new corrals for its larger shopping carts and waiting stalls for Drive Up pickups. The Star counted 10 of those pickup stalls. Newsday reported that the change required a variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals, granted in June 2025, taking the lot from 1,253 spaces to 1,247. According to the Star, Planning Board Chairwoman Jacqui Lofaro raised concerns about the precedent it could set for future tenants, even after a Kimco representative said there were "no parking issues" at the site.
In 1972 the fight was over whether the building should exist at all. In 2025 it came down to the color of a concrete sphere and six parking spaces.
The two years the box sat empty
Kmart closed on October 20, 2024, after 25 years. Before it shut, Newsday quoted Southampton Councilman Tommy John Schiavoni: "there are plenty of people who are blue collar who work here, who shop at Kmart."
For the next two years, the South Fork had no full-size discount anchor. According to 27east, the closest Target had been in Riverhead. At the opening, store director Adriana Fitzpatrick spoke to the outlet about East End villages and hamlets "where shoppers often have to travel long distances" for this kind of store, calling the Bridgehampton location "the perfect one-stop shop for busy residents and families in our community."
What the store adds to a November errand run
The details that matter after Labor Day are hours, services, and the pharmacy. Target's opening fact sheet lists the following for the Bridgehampton store:
- Hours: 7 a.m. to 11 p.m., Sunday through Saturday
- Size: about 90,000 square feet, with roughly 140 staff
- Services: Drive Up, Order Pickup, and same-day delivery through Target Circle 360
- Inside: a Starbucks café and a CVS Pharmacy, which 27east reports was scheduled to open after the store
The 11 p.m. closing is the line on that list that changes the most. On a stretch of Montauk Highway where many seasonal businesses cut their hours after summer, there is now a large store that sells groceries and household goods well into the evening every night of the week. 27east also reported that the store carries adult beverages and what company representatives called a "food-forward" shopping experience.
The CVS is the one service still on the way. Newsday quoted Target spokeswoman Eboni Wingo as saying the pharmacy would be added in early November. In mid-October, Spark Hamptons noted that Target's website already listed pharmacy hours and a direct number, 631-296-5006, which suggested it might open early. Before moving a prescription, call that number and confirm the pharmacy is filling orders.
The rest of the lot
Having the anchor back puts more of a weekly errand loop in one parking lot. Kimco's property page lists these tenants at Bridgehampton Commons:
- Groceries: King Kullen
- Home and general retail: TJ Maxx, Marshalls/HomeGoods, Williams-Sonoma, Barnes & Noble, Staples, Petco, Ulta
- Pharmacy and health: Walgreens, GoHealth Urgent Care
- Local specialty shops: Bridgehampton Wine Cellar, The Tack Trunk, Wild Birds, Color Me Mine
- Quick food: American Pie, Panera Bread, Dunkin'
The center's separate store directory still listed Target as "Coming Soon" in late October, so expect a few online listings to trail what is actually open. With Walgreens already in the lot and the CVS on its way, the Commons will soon have two pharmacy counters in one shopping center.
The opening weeks also landed just before a busy Thanksgiving stretch. Hampton Library closes at 5 p.m. on Wednesday, November 25, and stays closed on Thanksgiving Day. Art of Eating, which cooks in Bridgehampton, takes holiday orders through Friday, November 20, for pickup on Thursday, November 26. With a store open until 11 p.m. on Montauk Highway, the forgotten roasting pan or extra bag of ice no longer means a drive west.
What goes into the big building at the Commons, and what it looks like from Montauk Highway, has been worked out locally since 1972. If you are weighing how changes like this one affect a property near the Bridgehampton corridor, Dennis Saglam offers a confidential consultation on what Southampton Town's planning decisions mean for your plans.