Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Properties
A cedar-shingled home at dusk, with warm light behind closed glass, a fieldstone chimney, and a weathered bluestone terrace edged by oakleaf hydrangeas.

The Talkhouse Stays Open All Winter on Purpose. Here's What's on Its Stage Through December.

October 15, 2026

"We're open year round; it's not like we're making money in the winter," Ruby Honerkamp told Southforker in August. "It's more just to ensure there's an establishment for locals, and we're not like a big name pop up that's just popping up in the summer and closing our doors the second Labor Day swifts away."

This fall the Town of East Hampton has given that quote some weight. Highway Restaurant & Bar at 290 Montauk Highway planned to close after dinner service on Labor Day, 27east reported. In Montauk, Herb's Market, a grocery, deli and butcher shop open since 1963, said it would close permanently at the end of September, according to The East Hampton Star. Meanwhile, the Stephen Talkhouse at 161 Main Street in Amagansett is putting out a full October calendar. Its owners treat the off-season as the reason the place exists, not as a lull to get through. And this year, the Talkhouse's own history ends its year at Guild Hall on December 17.

Thirty-nine years, written down

The Talkhouse spent its summer documenting itself. "Bar," a 400-page limited-edition book, came out on July 25 and had a formal launch the next day. It's a mix of photographs, archival memorabilia, and recollections from staff, patrons and family. It's organized in four chapters, from the bar's opening more than 50 years ago to recent years. Gráfica Maiadouro, a family-run printer in Maia, Portugal, produced a first batch of 500 copies, which the Talkhouse sells online for $160.

The book has deep local roots. The East Hampton Star's editorial board noted that the Star's own Christopher Walsh conducted many of the interviews more than a decade ago. Ted Delano, a longtime patron, was lead editor. Ruby Honerkamp told Southforker that the family went through several versions before settling on many voices instead of a single narrator. That's where the subtitle "told by many" comes from.

The Star tied the book to the 39th anniversary of the partners led by Peter Honerkamp. He bought the bar in 1987, and his son and daughter, Max and Ruby, have since taken on leadership roles. The business ran under the Stephen Talkhouse name from 1970. It began as a lobster-and-steak restaurant with live music once or twice a week, then in the 1980s became a bar where regulars danced to a jukebox.

The summer version gets the headlines

August was the Talkhouse at full summer scale. John Mayer played an exclusive SiriusXM concert there on Wednesday, August 26, with a preshow conversation hosted by Andy Cohen, and 27east reported it was recorded for broadcast. The Star's editorial listed this summer's other names: Jackie Greene, G.E. Smith, Suzanne Vega, Christone "Kingfish" Ingram, Neal Francis, Low Cut Connie, Joan Osborne, Martin Sexton, Rhett Miller, the Record Company and Steve Earle. It described the summer months as drawing "hundreds of visitors and residents alike" night after night.

The same editorial says that even after a 1994 expansion, the club "is tiny, remaining an almost unbelievably intimate space." In a room that small, the season changes the experience more than any other variable. Summer brings in national acts and big crowds. October is a different arrangement.

How the room works after September

The Talkhouse's own FAQ splits the year in two. From May through September, there's usually someone in the office from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. In the off-season, the venue says, "we're in and out," and asks callers to leave a name, number and a good time to call back. The booking terms change too. Bands that want to play are told to do their own promotion and to:

expect to play for the door during the off season.

That one line explains how the calendar works. When a band plays for the door, its pay depends on who walks in, so off-season acts tend to be the ones with a local or regional following. The FAQ asks bands to describe exactly that following when they pitch. The fall lineup is built around people who already live within driving distance.

A few practical details from the same page still apply in October. Doors usually open at 7 p.m., and "many regulars are here at that time." A VIP ticket holds a reserved seat until the announced showtime. A general admission ticket gets you into the club, with bar and rail seats going to whoever arrives first. For dance-oriented shows, the tables come out and every ticket costs the same. If you're coming by Hampton Jitney, the drop-off is about a five-minute walk away.

The rest of October, night by night

As of October 12, the Talkhouse calendar runs Thursday through Saturday for the rest of the month:

  • Thursday, October 15: Rebel Elle
  • Friday, October 16: JOHNNYSWIM, then Dani & The Pespi Boys
  • Saturday, October 17: JOHNNYSWIM, then VHS
  • Thursday, October 22: Nancy Atlas
  • Friday, October 23: Nick Aiello, then LHT
  • Saturday, October 24: ECLIPSE, billed as Long Island's Tribute to Pink Floyd, then Midnight Sun
  • Thursday, October 29: James Puccio & The Good Grounders
  • Friday, October 30: Annie Trezza, then Karaoke!! w/ JBM
  • Saturday, October 31: The Cherry Bombs, then a Halloween Party w/ Hello Brooklyn

The calendar online covers October only. November and December dates weren't posted when this was written, so check it again before planning around a specific night later in the year.

Several of these nights overlap with events elsewhere in town. On Friday, October 30, Guild Hall holds a Halloween Silent Disco Dance Party from 7 to 10 p.m., the same night as Annie Trezza and karaoke in Amagansett. On Saturday, October 31, LongHouse Reserve runs Canines in Costume from 10:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., hours before the Talkhouse's Halloween double bill. Two weeks earlier, on Saturday, October 17, LongHouse holds Autumn Resonance sound healing from 9 to 10 a.m., the morning of the second JOHNNYSWIM night.

The book's story moves to Guild Hall on December 17

The Talkhouse year ends in a room much bigger than the bar. On Thursday, December 17, from 7 to 8:30 p.m., Guild Hall hosts "BAR: Told by Many – Celebrating the Stephen Talkhouse." It's an evening based on the book, with Peter and Ruby Honerkamp sharing Talkhouse stories alongside rotating special guests. Nancy Atlas leads the house band, and a book sale and signing follow. Atlas also has the Talkhouse stage to herself on October 22, so a fall regular could see her in both settings two months apart.

Tickets are sold through Guild Hall's online checkout. Neither the event page nor the listing gave a price when this was written.

Guild Hall's December calendar fills in around that night. National Theatre Live's "The Misanthrope" screens Friday, December 18, from 7 to 8:45 p.m. A Family Day runs Saturday, December 19, from 1 to 3 p.m. On Sunday, December 20, "National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation" plays as a free community screening from 7 to 8:45 p.m. The 86th Artist Members Exhibition and "Michael A. Butler: Somewhere in Time" are on view through that whole week.

Between now and then

The roughly seven weeks between the last October show and the Guild Hall evening have a few fixed dates elsewhere in town. In Springs, "Susan Vecsey at the Pollock-Krasner House" is up through December 13, and the artist gives a talk there on Sunday, November 1, at 2 p.m. On Saturday, November 7, from 7 to 8:30 p.m., Guild Hall presents Silkroad Up Close with Kaoru Watanabe, Kinan Azmeh and Maeve Gilchrist.

Those are single dates. The Talkhouse is the venue in that group that stays open as a bar between them, and Ruby Honerkamp told Southforker the point is to keep "the lights on for the community no matter the occasion." The Star's editorial ended by congratulating Peter, Max and Ruby Honerkamp and wrote, "Long may they and the Talkhouse run."

When a home in Amagansett or East Hampton is used across all four seasons, the off-season counts as much as July. At Dennis Saglam, we advise owners and buyers across the South Fork with that full year in mind, in Amagansett and every other part of the Town. Schedule a confidential consultation.

Follow Us On Instagram