Anyone who drives Montauk Highway through Water Mill has passed the shopping centers at the same red light. A Los Angeles investment group just paid a record sum to own them.
The record price puts a new spotlight on what happens next.
The deal itself
In May, as 27east reported, Runyon Group and River Oaks Properties closed on Water Mill Square at 670 Montauk Highway and The Mill (formerly known as the Water Mill Shoppes) at 760 Montauk Highway for a combined $39 million, a record price for commercial property in the area, according to The Real Deal. Together the two buildings total roughly 50,000 square feet and nearly 30 individual retail, restaurant and professional spaces, which brokers estimate is about 84 percent of all the retail leasing space in the entire hamlet. Whoever owns these two buildings essentially owns downtown Water Mill.
The sellers were Robert Zecher and Benjamin Rinzler of Vault Development Partners. Rinzler's family had owned Water Mill Square for years, and the pair had picked up The Mill in 2023 for $13.1 million. Three years later, the combined portfolio sold for nearly three times that figure. As 27east reported, Zecher called the sale the completion of a "renaissance" he and his father had started when they first bought in, and said he was looking forward to watching the new owners carry the vision forward.
Why the plaza commanded a record price
Here is the part that should reframe how you think about that traffic light. As The Real Deal reported, Joseph Miller, one of Runyon's co-founders, told the Southampton Town Planning Board that congestion at the intersection has historically caused people to avoid the shopping center altogether. His partner, Adam Frank of River Oaks, described the same traffic as a reason the deal made sense in the first place.
"From a real estate perspective, it's an A+. You have to drive by it going East and going back to the city."
That is the tension sitting underneath this whole story. Traffic near Water Mill Square is part of what makes the location attractive to retailers: drivers pass it going east and on the way back to the city. Miller has been watching this particular stretch of road for a decade, waiting for the buildings to reach critical mass. Once the combined footprint crossed close to 50,000 square feet, he said, it finally became interesting enough to buy. The question now is whether the owners can turn that visibility into a reason for drivers to stop.
Runyon's track record backs up the bet. The firm built its reputation placing brands like Aesop, Blue Bottle and Le Labo into its Platform development in Culver City, then applied the same playbook to The Post Montecito, a boutique retail project it bought and fixed up in 2022 and sold this spring. If that model holds here, tenanting could be central to the next chapter for these centers.
What actually changes this summer
If you were expecting bulldozers, you can relax for now. In a June interview with The Real Deal, Miller was blunt about the pace:
"This summer will feel mostly like last summer. We just closed, and we're just trying to run the buildings well and make sure current tenants are successful."
He confirmed the firm is working with the Water Mill Citizen Advisory Committee and the Town of Southampton on a renovation plan. As of this spring, a Runyon spokesperson said the company was not yet sure when it would bring a formal proposal to the town. The near-term plan is limited to paint and landscaping. No added square footage. Nothing that requires a zoning fight this year.
That restraint is deliberate. Runyon and River Oaks have retained Pegasus Investments Real Estate Advisory as asset manager and are moving through the town's process as they develop their renovation plan. It suggests the transformation here is going to be slower and more curatorial than the demolition-and-rebuild story some residents may be bracing for.
What is on the table for later
As 27east reported, the longer-range plan laid out to the Planning Board before the sale even closed gives a clearer picture of where this is headed:
- Subdividing some of the larger, underused spaces, including the former Blockbuster and SoulCycle footprint, to grow the number of individual storefronts from 19 to 22 without expanding the buildings
- A redesigned central green at The Mill, with Mattituck landscape architect Stacy Paetzel drawing up denser plantings along Montauk Highway to buffer the space from traffic while still keeping it visible from the road
- New building facades intended to bring the plaza closer to the architectural character of Bridgehampton or Southampton's Main Street, which Miller has said Water Mill currently lacks
- Room on the green for small farmers market style stands, an idea Planning Board member Kate Fullam raised directly, noting that local farmers and food producers often cannot afford standard retail rents
The Sagaponack General Store's recent revival was cited by 27east as a model for "appropriate" redevelopment. It offers a useful reference point here: a modest footprint, a facelift instead of a teardown, and a tenant mix connected to the East End.
The timing is not a coincidence
Downtown Water Mill is not gaining new foot traffic by accident this year. Watermill Crossing, a 38-unit luxury townhouse development, was completed immediately adjacent to The Mill, putting dozens of new households within walking distance of whatever ends up filling those storefronts. That is the kind of quiet infrastructure fact that rarely makes it into a "what's opening" roundup but explains a lot about why an investor would bet on this particular block right now.
The cultural calendar is cooperating too. The Parrish Art Museum, a short drive up the road, has three shows running through the fall that give residents a reason to make Water Mill a stop rather than a pass-through: a comprehensive survey of Tony Bechara running through November 1, the two-part exhibition "Until the Moon Comes Over the Mountain" on view through November 8, and Sanford Biggers' "Drift," his first major solo museum show on the East End. A few miles over, the Water Mill Museum has gallery events scheduled for September 6, September 26 and October 13. None of this is retail, but it is the kind of steady, non-seasonal draw that makes a redevelopment bet like Runyon's look less speculative and more like it is catching a wave that was already forming.
What to actually watch for
If you want to track this rather than just hear about it secondhand, the real signal will not be construction fencing. It will be the Southampton Town Planning Board's calendar. As of this spring, no formal renovation application had been filed, so any zoning discussion, including the proposed jump from 19 to 22 storefronts, will show up there first. Until then, expect the same tenants, the same traffic and a fresh coat of paint, with the more visible changes arriving on the town's timeline rather than the buyer's.
The short version: traffic at that light is a concern for some drivers and part of the site's visibility to motorists.
If you are weighing what a shift like this means for property values or timing on the South Fork, Dennis Saglam tracks these filings as closely as the sales themselves. Schedule a confidential consultation to talk through what it's actually worth to you.